You’ll want a PFD that’s light, comfortable, and easy to take off, since you’ll probably won’t want to wear it on longer portages.
MTI Reflex PFD
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c09fd/c09fdb504489424c7672601b92ced779edf40184" alt="MTI Reflex PFD"
I’d suggest looking for a PFD that’s trimly cut, like the ($75). The Reflex is slim, designed for paddling, and has fully adjustable shoulder straps, two zippered cargo pockets, and a tough nylon shell. It’s not fancy, but it’s highly effective.
Another company to check out is Kokatat, which makes cleanly designed PFDs like the ($100). Kokatata gave the Bahia a big zippered chest pocket, an easy-to-grab main zipper, and generous mesh for ventilation, a bonus if you paddle mostly in hot weather. I’m also a fan of its easily adjustable straps, which help dial in the right fit. Best of all, the Bahia’s back is shaped to accommodate seats, making it a great choice if you kayak, too.
I’m planning a late spring or early summer canoe trip in southern Ontario and I need a new personal flotation device. The trip involves several portages per day and will last a week, so my new PFD needs to be light and comfortable. What should I get?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/052dc/052dc96c2e91a409779b564f22fa2e4ade4113e2" alt="Astral Designs Abba PFD"
Women may want to check out the ($130). It’s cut for a woman’s body, with stretchy side panels and fully adjustable straps. It also has fleece-lined hand warmer pockets, a very nice touch, and big front pockets with a key loop. The flotation material is kapok, a soft, natural fiber that floats well.
I’m planning a late spring or early summer canoe trip in southern Ontario and I need a new personal flotation device. The trip involves several portages per day and will last a week, so my new PFD needs to be light and comfortable. What should I get?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/31f19/31f193d5bbb055656d0b9eb8ee871855a9d1b364" alt="Mustang Survival Deluxe Inflatable PFD"
You might also consider an inflatable PFD. The advantage here is a lack of bulk—they fit much more like fishing vests than a traditional PFDs. Some models are “automatic,” meaning they’ll inflate when exposed to water. Of course, for multiple-portage trips when you’re in and out of the water voluntarily, that may not be a good thing. In that case, a model with a ripcord-like inflation initiator would work nicely. A good example is Mustang Survival’s ($210), which feels more like a rolled-up towel across your shoulders than a life jacket. True, you need to be confident that you’ll be in a position to pull the cord when you need to, but when canoeing, chances are you’ll be okay.