I think paddle, absolutely. Theres nothing wrong with pedal kayaks, but theyre somewhat specialized. Fishers like them as they allow very quiet hands-free propulsion over shoals where fish may be waiting. Nature-watchers like them for the same reason.
Wilderness Systems Pamlico 160T
Pamlico 160TIts true that pedal power yields a natural, fairly non-fatiguing way to propel a boat (your thigh muscles are the strongest ones on the body). But you lose some maneuverability. You lose some safety features (paddles are useful for a number of things, although you can always pack one along). And you lose that traditional feel” of kayaking.
Of course, which paddle kayak you get will depend a lot on budget. For your purposes, I think the Manitou 13 ($829) would work great, as its a boat that combines some touring and recreational features. It has a nice, roomy cockpit and good stability. And its polyethylene hull is durable. If you decide some overnight trips are in your future, the larger Tsunami 175 ($1,500) offers more storage, an optional rudder, and a cockpit with lots of adjustments for more comfort. Its a nice boat, but, of course, youll be getting up there in price if you buy two.
How about a tandem? Another Wilderness Systems boat, the Pamlico 160T ($1,175), seats two and can even handle a little surf should you find some. It comes with a rudder and has easily adjusted seats.
I will say that pedaling has its appeal. Do you see pedal boats in the waters where you want to spend time? Maybe ask around, get some opinions. The Mirage Outfitter ($2,200) a tandem pedal boat, actually looks like it would be a lot of fun.
The ϳԹ Buyer’s Guide for Summer 2008 is on newsstands now. Look for it online soon.