Saucony ProGrid Outlaw
The Outlaw鈥檚 high-wrapping upper serves as a snow-and-debris gaiter and adds ankle stability on fast and nasty downhills. Even better, the height drops down in the back, allowing for greater movement around the Achilles. Factor in its surprisingly light weight and great traction and you鈥檝e got our favorite foul-weather shoe, despite the somewhat stiff and slower forefoot. 10.1 oz
TAGS: MOUNTAINS, MUD
Pearl Izumi SyncroFuel II
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5354c/5354c873e1625947cf43a375f4983c5a48f606ea" alt="Pearl Izumi Synchro Fuel II"
One word: plush! The thickly cushioned SyncroFuel II is as smooth as a heel-striking high-mileage trainer can get, with an impressively quick turnover, a firm and high-energy forefoot, and a touch of stability in the soft heel for light pronators. Bonus: the tight mesh sidewalls on that seamless upper boost both warmth and splash resistance. 9.2 oz
TAGS: HEEL STRIKERS, STABILITY
Salomon Speedcross 3CS
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/85556/85556a650ecaba0634b8a7b3fe6acb352afda916" alt="Salomon Speedcross 3 CS"
Waterproof, fast, and extremely nimble, the Speedcross 3 CS is a lot like one of our other favorite aggressive mountain running shoes, the La Sportiva Crosslite 2 (page 92). Except it鈥檚 winterized: the forefoot鈥檚 water-shunning Climate Shield membrane kept the shoe warm and dry on sloppy days, and the lugs are big enough to bite firm snow without feeling gummy on packed dirt. 9.9 oz
TAGS: WATERPROOF, TRAIL READY
Merrell Lithe Glove
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/198f7/198f7343deb7b73bcd5c11dca2ee9253635a67d0" alt="Merrell Lithe Glove"
An ultraminimalist for winter. The Lithe is Merrell鈥檚 take on a barefoot-like running shoe but with a soft-shell upper for a bit of protection from water and cold weather. The Vibram sole is thin but felt just sturdy enough to beat back sharp pebbles. 鈥淓ven though it鈥檚 a minimalist shoe, it provides a good amount of protection,鈥 one converted tester crooned. 6.5 oz
TAGS: BAREFOOT-INSPIRED, SOFT SHELL
Scott eRide Support
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4da0a/4da0aa6b0c515823f82ee968bd6684426f1470f1" alt="Scott eRide Support"
Meet rockered running shoes. The curved midsole means there鈥檚 less heel to get in the way for midfoot strikers, and heel pounders roll quickly out of the cushy backseat. Testers split into two camps鈥攖hose who loved the smooth, forward-rolling feeling, and those who found it distracting. Either way, it鈥檚 a light, secure, slightly faster-than-average stability trainer with support for midrange over-pronators. 8.6 oz
TAGS: ROCKERED, FAST
Mizuno Wave Enigma
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ee41f/ee41fcacd91f5ee44bb61416225685e4ef5fd27c" alt="Mizuno Wave Enigma"
Like an Iowa glad-hander, the Enigma works hard to please everyone. It鈥檚 not too fat in the heel for midfoot strikers, not too firm for hard-landers. It鈥檚 also just thick enough in the forefoot to neutralize impact without seeming to sap your energy. Although it feels a touch slower than most Mizunos we鈥檝e tested, this versatile shoe hits a very sweet spot for the vast majority of high-mileage neutral runners. 9.6 oz
TAGS: MARATHONS, VERSATILE