Roof of the World, Center of a Universe Jostling between the spiritual and the secular in Kathmandu, once and future base camp for all manner of quests “And the wildest dreams of Kew are but the facts of Kathmandu.” The Profane It’s late for Kathmandu, already almost midnight, and I cling to the shoulders of photojournalist Tom Laird as we lurch down deserted, shuttered alleys on his motor scooter, cruising Sherpa pubs, two queris on the chhang trail of the Snow Leopard. Queri is Nepali slang for Westerners; it means “white eyes,” a coy play on the word quero, meaning “cloud.” Queri ayo, villagers Chhang is Tibetan-style homemade barley beer, and Laird, a veteran of the rock-and-roll raj, lingers in the doorway of each dim establishment we visit, vacuuming up the sweet fermenty harvest-fragrance of the brew, barking at me to Smell it! Smell it!, not hearing my recommendation to Drink it! Drink it! But the sad fact is that each chhang bar we come to, the Snow Leopard has I guess you could call Laird a Sherpaphile — who isn’t in this town, the world capital of adventure, the Rome of the hip universe, where the Grand Tour in the sixties and seventies traveled east to become the Great Trek and the Great Pilgrimage, where 335 outfitters and agencies compete with the city’s thousands of shrines, icons, and strange objects of veneration, Laird lived for several years up in the Khumbu region below Everest, home ground of the Sherpas, recording the community’s traditional songs and folklore, chumming around with high-altitude heroes like the Snow Leopard. The Snow Leopard is the nom de guerre of Ang Rita, the man who’s summited Sagarmatha, the Nepali name for Mount Everest, more times than anybody else, alive or A prodigious achievement, but the excitable photographer doesn’t really approve, single-mindedly disgusted by the Sherpa rate of attrition up on the summits. “Those peaks are sacred!” Laird rants over the whine of the scooter. “The white guys came in and bent the Sherpa world view from mountain as god to mountain as goal. The Tengboche lama says he never gave anybody permission We pull up to the entrance of a courtyard flanked on one side by a shabby concrete apartment building. Laird’s eyes narrow behind his wire-rimmed glasses and he whips off his helmet, swinging it in a wide arc to emphasize his point. Even with the engine turned off, Laird is loud. I sort of like it when he yells; I like the passionate investment in the issues, the suddenly “I’ll hire Sherpas to haul my ass up Everest,” he says, “when people start killing their caddies to play golf.” I don’t know where we are exactly — some centuries-old neighborhood on the edge of Kathmandu, the low skyline broken by the fabulous tiered roofs of pagodas. We’ve been getting closer and closer throughout the night, and now we’ve come to the end of the trail, a clean, brightly lit, two-table restaurant with silk kattas draped along its walls and around the necks of its Despite the mountain caddies turned into blocks of ice in the service of other people’s obsessions, and even though Laird insists that just because the Sherpas have played along with our goals doesn’t mean they’ve accepted them as their own, one thing’s for certain: The queris have been very, very good for Sherpas. In the 30 years that travelers have been storming Nepal, Another round of chhang for my men and horses. Our feet scuff a free-market strewing of happy-hour handbills as we walk through Thamel — ground zero in Kathmandu’s tourist boom — headed for the Maya Pub, the only place that seems to be open, clomping up a steep, narrow flight of stairs to the funky bar. “Don’t you just love that smell of shit and incense?” Laird says happily. Hepatitis has kept him away from
As recently as 1947, Nepal was the largest inhabited country on earth yet to be explored by Europeans, and the life expectancy was a prehistoric 24 years. When you enter the second half of the twentieth century as a medieval and in many ways pre-feudal kingdom sandwiched between a newly independent India and a newly communist China, and make a conscious decision to modernize, you probably ought to expect some whiplash. In rush the not-always-farsighted do-gooders, outfits like the World Health Organization, to take one example. They set up clinics, eradicate disease, train people to take better care of themselves, make a dent in the infant mortality rate, accomplish noble, generous objectives, but my goodness, someone forgot the birth control pills, the population triples, and here comes a housing shortage, a food shortage, accelerated environmental degradation, unemployment, and a bloated bureaucracy slurping on the platinum teats of the Lords of Poverty: competing donor nations, international developmental aid organizations such as the World Bank, self-righteous NGOs and vanity charities, carelessly recycling Big Money through the Third World. And Big Money, folks, leaves Big Footprints. Thanks in part to the global homogenizing of this subtle but virulent form of colonialism, Nepal’s seemingly endemic problems are not especially unique. You give us your problems, we give you ours. The nature of migration only intensifies the dynamic. ϳԹ tourism: an outflow of the affluent into the tribal world. Immigration: an inflow of diversity into the established Still, it’s tricky, this not-always-sincere experiment called development. Once you let the Coca-Cola out of the bottle, the landscape is going to change regardless of any effort to preserve it, but how much for the better and how much for the worse? Suppose you run a charity and decide to bring electricity to all the monasteries in Mustang, which have somehow managed to In the eighties, Tengboche became something of a microcosm of what adventure travel had done to Nepal. During the high season, a thousand trekkers a day were cruising through; monks would just throw off their robes and join the expeditions, and the lama was hard-pressed to deal with the situation. Today Tengboche, rebuilt since the 1989 blaze, is no less a freeway. Apple pie,
“Democracy,” says Laird, “has unleashed the floodgates of desire without any of the structures to fulfill them!” “What?” I stare at my immoderately eloquent companion over a glass of local vodka. “What did you say?” Laird, I think, must stand in front of a mirror and practice these lines. Nepal’s infant democracy, in fact, has been the photographer’s ticket to ride. From the eighteenth century until 1950, power in the kingdom was jockeyed between two dynastic families, the Shahs and the Ranas — not exactly a civic-minded bunch. An India-sponsored mini-revolution ended with the creation of a coalition government in 1951. Nine years and ten governments After a sleepless night, he got back in touch with Koirala. In 1952, the Swiss geologist Toni Hagen had been the first and virtually the last Westerner permitted to visit Mustang, the magical high-desert valley north of the snow peaks on the old salt-trade route between Tibet and India. But with the end of the Cold War, the gates to off-limits border areas were being cautiously
Laird wanted to go to Mustang, too, record the antiquities with his camera. Done, said the PM, have a nice trip, and Laird became the first foreigner ever to live in Mustang for a year, and the first to get a permit to cross the border to visit Mount Kailas, Tibet’s most sacred peak. For years, the people of Mustang had been begging the Nepalese government to open up the valley for a piece of the touristic pie, and now it happened, the ancient kingdom intimately married to the world for better or worse, richer or poorer, in no small part because of Laird’s collaboration with Peter Matthiessen, who later joined the photographer in Mustang and wrote the text for the published collection of Laird’s mesmerizing images, East of Lo Monthang. But nobody, not even the rabidly sensitive Laird, can go to such far-flung places without dragging in the microbes of transformation. His own demand to prohibit the use of outside porters caused the price of wheat to double, and he frets, however belatedly, that Mustang will soon become an anthropological zoo. Nepalese politics have continued to be steadily unsteady, as befits a newborn democracy. In 1991 the Nepali Congress Party won a majority in the elections, but despite the dismantling of Marxist-Leninist regimes in the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe, the Communist Party of Nepal placed a red-hot second. Six years later, even as Laird and I sit in the Maya Pub, ballots for But there’s more. Among the reds is a splinter group of pyscho-rad communists who identify themselves as Maoists and broadcast nothing but contempt for their houseboy compa˜eros. Thus in early 1996, to gear up for the forthcoming election, the lunatic faction announced it was starting a people’s war. For the last week, every time I picked up a Kathmandu paper, I was The geopolitics of tourism can tilt either way: the foreigner as valuable friend and ally (Tibet), the foreigner as enemy, scapegoat, and pawn (Kashmir). “Is it true,” I ask Laird, “what I’ve been reading about the Maoists?” “Yep,” he nods. For the moment at least, the terrorists have been operating mostly in the jungles and in the midwest, nontourist regions, though he recently heard about a Maoist demonstration at Jiri, the roadhead for the Everest trek. I had been told that the American embassy was under pressure from the Nepalese government not to publicize Maoist shenanigans, allegedly because “Is it true,” I asked the secretary of tourism and civil aviation, the affable D. P. Dhakal, who sat behind his desk in Kathmandu’s palatial parliamentary compound, jiggling his head in that curious way Nepalis have, “that you’re trying to start a tourist campaign over the top of a Maoist insurrection?” “Tourism is a thing which is totally aloof from politics,” Dhakal said with the fine assurance of a man who works and lives in the capital of a country with a centralized government. “Yes, the Maoist thing grows, but it cannot be there forever. They did it for elections. They did it for attention.” Surprisingly, Dhakal cited the “positive” example of Sri Lanka, how the violence When the minister sighed that “the attention of the media gets attached disproportionately” to negatives, I mustered a thimble of sympathy and let the whole mess drop, wondering instead what sort of push he was involved in to inaugurate Visit Nepal ’98. (Motto: “A sustainable habitat through sustainable tourism.”). He shrugged and sat back cavalierly in his chair. “Our society As I left his office, Dhakal had urged me to put the Maoist situation into the “proper perspective,” whatever that perspective was. The Maya Pub closes down around us, people stumbling toward the door, and we’re back on the streets of Thamel, swarmed by insomniac teenage ricksha drivers. “Come on,” says Laird. “Let’s drive around.” We glide down twisting alleys, lines of freshly outdated election posters crisscrossed above us like the city’s forgotten laundry. Laird points out the former Cabin Restaurant, infamous during the Nepal Gold Rush for its hashish menu. We cruise Freak Street, park, duck through a doorless entrance, and Laird proudly shows me where he used to live in the Third Eye Lodge, only now “You can’t imagine how far away this was in 1972,” says Laird, peering into the dark at his memories, his face aglow with nostalgia. “Santana was booming out on the street the first night I spent in this room. You can look around and just see those fucking pyschedelic hippies coming out of the corners. We were so desperate to get somewhere. When you came over and saw those Ah, Freak Street, the epicenter of the countercultural fantasy, the Haight-Ashbury of Asia, where the rock-and-roll raj reclined on pillows of dreamy hash, having traveled the overland route from Europe across Turkey, Iran, Afghanistan, Pakistan, and Goa into the Buddhist heart of the biggest playground ever. Freak Street, where yesterday’s hippies came to lose themselves in Kathmandu became Asia’s emblematic antithesis to Vietnam and the lurid Conradian lust for darkness, the apparent antidote for all the bad knowledge Western civilization seemed to be coughing up like blood clots. Light was Kathmandu’s essence. Butter lamps instead of napalm. Puja instead of paranoia. Here in Kathmandu the exotic was timeless and transcendent, inherently Finally Laird scoots me back to the Kathmandu Guest House, legendary for being the Ritz of the downscale queris all those many years ago. The proprietor has just built a deluxe hotel in Nagarkot, on the ridgeline above the city, which gives you some idea about how eagerly the people of Kathmandu have embraced the adventure travel phenomenon. Dawn comes with a village sound The Sacred From the Kathmandu Post, May 22: “MORE FANFARE THAN DEVOTION MARKS BUDDHA’S ANNIVERSARY. “It is not only political chaos which hindered the people of the land of the Buddha from celebrating heart and soul the 2,541st birth anniversary of Lord Buddha, the light of Asia…. Most of the pilgrims at Swayambhu were there to freak out than to celebrate the holy day. Vendors selling cold drinks, music albums, pictures and handicrafts got prominence than devotees, and the In the quirky English of the subcontinent, the lament still sounds all too familiar. Even the divine takes it in the cosmic balls when insular kingdoms get drop-kicked out of their pasts into the nuclear age. On the outskirts of Kathmandu is a modest hill called Devbhumi, “Home of the Gods,” and it lifts the shrine of Swayambhu toward the nearby heavens, which reproduce the immensity of the stupa, magnifying and multiplying the dome of whiteness into the most soul-boggling horizon on the planet — the snow peaks of the Himalayas. The land of the Eight-Thousands, blasting up This is Nepal, where you climb a hill to expose yourself to the sacred, not shelter yourself from the profane — not Tuscany, where you might reasonably expect to find a fortress atop this breast of land jutting skyward off the valley floor. Kathmandu — never actually invaded, never actually colonized — has been forever too preoccupied with its conversation Devbhumi is where I’m headed this muggy afternoon to do something Kathmandu’s expatriate community seems loath to do, which is walk, walk anywhere in the urban morass, sucking in a dun-colored haze, the diesel fumes and the wood smoke and the dust and the atomized holy cow shit all bottled up in the valley’s thermal inversion to plunge Kathmandu’s air-quality index to a level I step past the rug merchants idle on their stoops, past Pilgrims Book House, its window full of trekking maps, and the Himalayan clinic whose lucky American doctor has just choppered down from an inaccessible part of the Tibetan border with Dick Blum following a walkabout around Mount Kailas. What fun to be a do-gooder in Kathmandu. Helicopters, advocates argue, don’t leave I cross Durbar Marg, one of the city’s most westernized boulevards, past pricey artifact outlets, the jewelry stores and gem retailers and vacation wholesalers, past Wimpy hamburgers with its coterie of hometown punks — McDonald’s execs are in town, paving the way for the Himalayas’ first franchise — and on up toward the royal palace, where Nepal’s constitutional If Thamel has changed much since its halcyon days, I couldn’t know and wouldn’t care. You shoulda been here 20, 30 years ago, the graying remnants of the hip community say with dismissive smiles and the sagging body language of bittersweet loss, staring off into a Felliniesque kaleidoscope of images that compose their collective past. The increasingly geriatric veterans of the “We discovered these places, Afghanistan, Nepal, Goa,” an old hippie named Jasmine told the writer Gita Mehta. “When we arrived everybody loved us. Now the whole damn world is on the trail we opened up, and the same people who loved us, fucking hate us. There’s too many of them.They’re not in the same class as those of us who got here first.” As far as life on the planet goes, we are certainly the last of the last generations to get there first. We boomers, Kennedy’s children, heirs to the Boeing 707, presided over the deconstruction of any and all frontiers and the death of myriad traditions. We are the last to see true wilderness, the last to see life as it had been lived for centuries. Thirty years ago I was a Now the rickety wooden towers are gone, replaced by condos and private clubs and tony restaurants, you can’t drive on the beach from Virginia to Carolina, the migrant fishermen exist only in history books, and I moved out of Hatteras forever ten years ago. Be here now? You can’t, not in a place where you have a history, however short. That’s the traveler’s ace in the hole So I walk, making the city my own. I turn down Tridevi Marg, deep into Thamel, one of many neighborhoods in Kathmandu which have transformed themselves into base camps for ϳԹ with a capital A. Shingle after shingle of local and international companies — one for every thousand of Nepal’s visitors each year — hawking their services for trekking, rafting, But where might you start to prevent Nepal’s macrocosmic drift toward cultural decline and deracination? Is tourism the problem, is adventure travel a form of designer imperialism? Hard to say, when tourism is just about the only industry Nepal can depend on to democratize its rural economy and spread the wealth, rupee by rupee. “Nepal has to have tourists,” says Nirmal Chabba, manager of the famed Hotel Yak & Yeti. (If you’re the sort who likes to dress elegantly and piss away money, the hotel has its own casino. Richard Gere and Bernardo Bertolucci prefer to rent the luxurious fairy-tale Tibetan palace suites on the seventh floor and meditate on their private terraces overlooking the city.) As In Thamel, every few steps someone’s hawking a khukri, a brass idol, a baseball hat embroidered with Buddha’s eyes, but Nepalis are either too proud or too shy to hit you with the hard sell, and history has so far spared Nepal from a culture of resentment toward foreigners. At the end of Tridevi Marg, I veer south and arrive at the old pilgrims’ junction that leads west out of “When you leave,” he says, an identical silky black gleam to his eyes and hair, “will you give me your extra shirts and pants?” Sham’s head only comes up to my belt buckle, but the discrepancy doesn’t faze him. All over the mountains, porters are walking around in tattered oversize down vests and tattered undersize sneakers. He’s used to wearing big clothes, he tells me, but “OK, no clothes,” says Sham. “Milk.” He wants milk. How coldhearted do you have to be to say get lost to a kid whose final appeal in this most clichëd of Third World shantytown vignettes is for milk? Still, I’m skeptical. I insist on accompanying Sham to a nearby shop to make the purchase myself, but it’s not a 20-cent pint carton he wants. He points behind the wooden counter to a top shelf holding a huge, The little bastard is probably working for the Milk Baba, a local Hindu ascetic who for 16 years has squeezed out a life for himself by refusing to put any nourishment other than milk into his body. “What are you planning to do, break it down into dime bags to sell to four-year-olds?” Sham doesn’t miss a beat. He’s got a shitload of brothers and sisters who apparently do nothing but sit around wailing for him to bring milk. “It is my duty,” he says manfully. I balk at the price — 300 rupees, a fortune in the shadows of Kathmandu’s kiddie economy. Sham will probably grow up to be one of Central Asia’s biggest criminals, perhaps even prime minister. “Why am I letting you talk me into this?” I wonder out loud, pulling a wad of bills from my pocket. “Because it’s Buddha Jayanti and you are going to the monkey temple.” Good answer. It’s Buddha’s birthday and I’m going to Swayambhu. Far be it for me, on such a day, on such a journey, to be the one to impede the flow of milk into the mouths of babes, innocent or otherwise. “Are you a buddhist?” the expats i pal around with in Kathmandu eventually get around to asking. They are, I’m not, but the answer’s never so simple. I confess I feel disconnected from the great theologies of man, abandoned to the scientist’s god, Technologia. I have no place reserved inside myself for Catholicism, the religion I was raised with, and little warmth for Despite Buddhism’s ubiquity, Nepal has ordained itself the world’s only Hindu kingdom, but as religions go, forget it. On my scorecard, Hinduism is the biggest freak show ever conceived, one carny act after another. I do, however, feel that cremation should be a spectator sport, especially for death-defying Westerners, and whenever I’m in Kathmandu I make a point of visiting I try to explain my feelings to the Kathmandu crowd — my relief in the presence of the Buddhist sense of humor, the lightness of the pleasure I find sometimes in a monk’s guileless grin, my appreciation for Buddhism’s spiritually generous posture of whateverness. Yet what I find most profoundly compelling about Buddhism is predoctrinal, postdogmatic, and has little to do “Oh!” Heads nod. “Then you’re a Buddhist.” Well, not so fast. An affinity is not faith, nor need it be, and there’s plenty about the religion I find disheartening. I believe in mountains and oceans, billowy flags whispering our frailty to the void, the accrued sanctity of places like Swayambhu, and I try — an effort made significantly easier by the Nepalese — to believe in the goodness of people. All the At the foot of Devbhumi I cross a bridge and fall in step with a parade of celebrants headed up a low ridge under a leafy canopy of trees. The entrance to the shrine looks like a refugee camp on holiday. Groups of families rock on their heels, sipping tea from thermoses, munching on fried dough or snow-white crescents of coconut. Laughing children run about with no sense of And perhaps no greater proof of such temptation than the daunting approach to Swayambhu: when you drop back your head and raise your downcast eyes, so attentive to your feet, and finally notice the pair of shikara, monolithic stone-and-brick towers like fat white rocket ships, stationed on each side of the highest landing. Shikara translates as “mountain peak,” and their forms I hump upward, my ears slowly filling with a glacial splintering of sound, the gravelly crackle of hundreds of human beings in motion. My eyes slide along the hemispheric curve of the stupa, along rising and converging lines of fluttering prayer flags, like permanently suspended confetti, toward the inevitable symmetry of the shrine’s little metaphysical joke. When you set your I sit down on a stone ledge, my sweaty back against the wall of a tiny shop and its interior breath of coolness, trying to get a fix on how it is, amidst this chaotic swirl of humanity, that one celebrates Buddha’s birthday in the land where the historical Siddhartha himself was born. For anyone who has tied his or her piety to churches or mosques or synagogues, Swayambhu and From Kathmandu’s quasi-punk point of view, Swayambhu is a terrific place for girl-watching. In the courtyard in front of the rest house the Nepali loverboys congregate, sniggering at a trio of fornicating dogs, their horny eyes tracking cliques of young women. With muffled snaps, a breeze steers the prayer flags toward the north and east, toward Everest, where climbers are The wind lifts the dust and flies. Trash blows across my feet. There’s birdsong and the bumblebee buzz of throaty chanting. Bells ring always but without a pattern; bells like Sunday church bells, like fire bells, like dinner bells, like we-have-another-winner. Out of nowhere, suddenly, monkeys scamper onto the stupa, playing Tarzan on a limp rope of old prayer flags, swinging As shadows lengthen, aproned Tibetan women begin filling the four tiers of brass butter lamps that ring the base of the stupa, a signal for me to unfold my legs and wander over to the observation platform that overlooks the valley and watch the sunset. But it’s the northeastern view that most engrosses me, out across the city, beyond the knob of otherworldly Bhaktapur and the Here’s the story of Swayambhu, and it begins with a geological fact: Once upon a time, the Kathmandu valley was an enormous shimmering lake cradled by its present-day bowl of mountains, where the first Buddha pitched a lotus seed. Eighty thousand years later, the darn thing blossomed magnificently, rising out of the water as big as a chariot wheel, a thousand-petaled flower A fine tale, of course. Another cartoon-colored, hallucinogenic panel in the frescoes of Kathmandu. And yet what did the sage Dubby Bhagat tell me? “It’s the mythology that keeps this country together — the stories, the narratives of the people.” I stare off across the luminous nightfall of the world’s most exotic valley to observe another Swayambhu levitate in the east above the storybook kingdoms of Bhutan and Sikkim, a glistening white stupa that swells and completes itself and becomes the full moon, and I suddenly recall that the wonderful Spanish phrase a dar luz — literally, “to give light” — means to The night turns milk-blue, ghostly, vaporous. The city animates light, and amplifies everything within a life. |